What is a Lady Bird Deed? Are Lady Bird Deeds Legal in South Carolina?

What is a Lady Bird Deed? Are Lady Bird Deeds Legal in South Carolina?

A lady bird deed, like other kinds of deeds, determines how ownership of a property is transferred and to whom. It’s similar to a life estate deed in that it allows the transfer of property outside of probate. But the big difference is that a lady bird deed gives the life tenant rights to the property that are restricted by a traditional life estate deed, such as the right to mortgage or sell the property.

A lady bird deed – also known as a ladybird deed or an enhanced life estate deed – can be a useful tool in the right estate plan. But it’s not right for everyone, and using a lady bird deed can lead to serious unintended consequences.

Let’s look at what a lady bird deed is and what it does, the advantages and disadvantages of the lady bird deed, and lady bird deeds in South Carolina.

What Is a Lady Bird Deed? What Does a Lady Bird Deed Do?

The lady bird deed was created by Florida attorney Jerome Ira Solkoff in the early 1980s; the name comes from Solkoff’s book and is not a reference to First Lady “Lady Bird” Johnson. Solkoff started using the lady bird deed to address an issue with the traditional life estate.

In a typical life estate, a piece of property (often but not always real estate) is owned by a “life tenant” for the duration of their life only. When the life tenant dies, the property automatically passes to a “remainderman” or “remaindermen.” The life tenant may be the grantor (the original owner of the property), the grantor’s spouse or child, or someone else.

One big advantage of a life estate deed is that the property is not subject to probate. But one big disadvantage – to the life tenant, at least – of the traditional life estate is that the life tenant does not have full rights to the property during their lifetime. The life tenant cannot, for example, sell or take out a mortgage on the property without the permission of the remainderman. Understandably, selling or mortgaging the property goes against the best interests of the remainderman, who would prefer for the property to remain intact with its full value. This clash of interests between the life tenant and the remainderman effectively means that, in most cases, the life tenant is unable to sell or mortgage the property, even if it is legally theirs.

Enter the lady bird deed. With a lady bird deed, the life tenant has full rights to the property during their lifetime, including the right to mortgage, sell, or otherwise dispose of the property without the permission of the remainderman. This is why the term “enhanced life estate” is also used for a lady bird deed, since it’s essentially a life estate deed that gives the life tenant additional rights to the property. Upon the death of the life tenant, the property, or what remains of it, automatically goes to the remainderman (or remaindermen).

Another important difference between a lady bird deed and a life estate deed is that a lady bird deed can be revoked or changed by the grantor alone. By contrast, a life estate deed can only be revoked or changed by the grantor with the permission of the life tenant and the remainderman.

Benefits of a Lady Bird Deed

As covered above, the main benefits of a lady bird deed over a life estate deed include:

• Full property rights to the life tenant including the right to sell or mortgage the property without the remainderman’s permission.
• Ability for grantor to revoke or change the lady bird deed without the remainderman’s permission.

Other benefits of a lady bird deed are the same as a typical life estate deed, which include:

• Avoiding probate. Because the lady bird deed (or life estate deed) directs where the property should go after death, the property passes automatically to the heir without needing to go through probate.
• Help with Medicaid eligibility. If the grantor is also the life tenant, then the property is not considered an asset when the grantor applies for Medicaid. Lady bird deeds aren’t considered a transfer for Medicaid eligibility purposes.
• Prevent property from being used to repay Medicaid. Lady bird deeds (and life estate deeds) prevent the property from being used to repay the state for Medicaid costs related to long-term care after the individual’s death.
• Avoid federal gift tax. Importantly, it does not help you avoid applicable estate taxes.

This list is not exhaustive. Depending on your specific circumstances, you may derive other benefits from a lady bird deed or life estate deed.

Drawbacks of a Lady Bird Deed and Potential Consequences

Lady bird deeds sound great. They provide all the benefits of a life estate deed but without the major drawback of restricting the life tenant’s rights. Plus, they can be changed or revoked by the grantor at will.

But there are two major drawbacks specific to lady bird deeds that can create unintended consequences. These are:

Drawback 1: Lack of widespread recognition

Lady bird deeds are not as common and widespread as life estate deeds and many other estate planning tools. As of now, only five states fully recognize lady bird deeds (usually called enhanced life estate deeds): Florida, Michigan, Texas, Vermont, and West Virginia.

While this doesn’t mean you are prohibited from having a lady bird deed if you live in one of the other forty-five states, it does mean that doing so is taking a risk. Your wishes may not be carried out as you want, because the law still isn’t clear on how to handle lady bird deeds in most states.

Drawback 2: Difficulty obtaining title insurance

One of the great benefits of a lady bird deed is that the life tenant does not require permission from the remainderman to mortgage, sell, or otherwise encumber or dispose of the property. But this can cause a problem when it comes to title insurance if the life tenant ever decides to sell or take out a mortgage on the property.

A title insurance company in a state where lady bird deeds are not routinely recognized may refuse to issue title insurance unless it has the “joinder of the remainder,” that is, the agreement of the remainderman or remaindermen to the sale or mortgage. Since, as discussed above, doing so goes against the remainderman’s best interests, it may be impossible to obtain the joinder of the remainder. At that point, the enhanced life estate created by the lady bird deed is no different than a typical life estate.

What if you simply don’t get title insurance and go ahead with the sale? It’s true that title insurance is not required for every sale. But skipping the title insurance doesn’t address the underlying problem, which is that the remainderman has a vested interest in the property and can bring a claim in the future. Fighting such claims in and out of court can be costly and time consuming, and they can irreparably damage relationships among heirs.

Are Lady Bird Deeds Legal in South Carolina?

Lady bird deeds are not codified into law in South Carolina, nor have they been officially recognized by the courts.

However, in at least two instances, South Carolina higher courts have agreed with the intention of an enhanced life estate, or, in its words, a “life estate with the power of disposition,” as far back as 1971. That is, it recognized the right of a life tenant to dispose of the property as they wish without the consent of the remaindermen when this wish was explicitly expressed in the original property owner’s last will. See Blackmon v. Weaver (2005) (here) and Johnson v. Waldrop (1971) (here).

This may be reassuring to those who wish to take advantage of the benefits of a lady bird deed in South Carolina, but it’s still a long way from being widely used and recognized here. Plus, it still doesn’t change the fact that title insurance companies may refuse to issue title insurance without the joinder of the remainder, which could hamper real estate deals. Finally, it’s worth noting that both of the “life estates with the power of disposition” recognized by the courts were created in last wills, not through deeds, meaning that the properties in question were subject to probate.

Alternatives to Lady Bird Deeds in South Carolina

At this time, the most prudent thing to do may be to find an alternative to the lady bird deed if you live in South Carolina or another state where enhanced life estate deeds are not routinely recognized. Some possible alternatives to a lady bird deed, depending on your objectives, include a life estate deed, a transfer-upon-death deed, or a revocable living trust.

If you have questions about your estate plan and are concerned about avoiding probate or ensuring that your property is inherited according to your wishes, call estate planning attorney Gem McDowell at the Gem McDowell Law Group. He and his team can help you create, review, or update your estate plan so it reflects your current life circumstances and future wishes. He can also help you understand the possible consequences of how your estate plan will play out and how that can affect your family members and heirs and prevent friction in the future.

Call Gem today at his office in Mount Pleasant, SC, at 843-284-1021 to schedule your free consultation today.